Caf Coach

Comparison

Caf Coach vs MyFitnessPal

Competitor facts checked on November 8, 2026 against the public pages linked under Sources. Prices and counts change; tell us at hello@cafcoach.org if something is out of date and we will fix it.

Short answer: MyFitnessPal is a general food diary with a huge database and a Premium tier ($19.99 a month or $79.99 a year) for barcode scanning and gram-level macro goals. It has no dining hall menus. Caf Coach is built for students on a meal plan: it loads today's cafeteria menu at 304 schools, plans your plate from it, and every feature is free. If most of your meals come from a dining hall, Caf Coach is the easier tool. If you cook and eat out, MyFitnessPal's database is hard to beat.

Side by side

Caf CoachMyFitnessPal
PriceFree. Every feature, no subscription.Free tier with ads. Premium $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year.
Your dining hall's menuYes. Today's menu at 304 schools, by meal period, with calories, protein, carbs and fat per item.No. You search a general database and hope the "grilled chicken" entry matches the one on your line.
Builds a meal planYes. Autopilot plans the day from what is being served so it hits your targets; Reshuffle swaps items.No. You log what you ate after the fact.
Custom macro goals in gramsFree. Built-in calculator for cut, maintain, bulk and recomp.Premium only. Free accounts set macros as percentages.
Barcode scanFree.Premium only.
Photo and label scanFree.Meal Scan is Premium only.
Food database sizeYour campus menu plus a general database for packaged and restaurant food. Smaller, on purpose.Very large, user-submitted, with duplicates and wrong entries mixed in.
Allergens and dietsYes. Filters narrow the menu to what you can eat; allergen panel per item.No menu filter; you read each entry.
Exercise trackingNo. Food only.Yes, plus device and app sync.
Apple HealthNot yet.Yes.
AdsYes, light, and they are how it stays free.Yes on the free tier; ad-free is Premium.
PlatformsiPhone, and any web browser. Android app in testing.iPhone, Android, web.
Who makes itMomentum Apps LLC, students at Harding University in Arkansas.MyFitnessPal, Inc., founded 2005.

Where Caf Coach is ahead

It knows what is for dinner. The hard part of tracking in a cafeteria is not the math, it is finding the right entry. MyFitnessPal asks you to search "chicken alfredo" and choose from hundreds of entries, none of which is the one your dining hall made. Caf Coach reads the menu your dining service publishes for today and shows you those exact items with the nutrition they list. You pick what you took and the numbers belong to the food in front of you.

It plans instead of just recording. Logging after the meal tells you what happened. Autopilot tells you what to do: a breakfast, lunch and dinner built from today's menu that land on your protein and calorie targets, with Reshuffle when you do not like a pick. Students who open the plan on the walk to the caf eat differently than students who log at 10 PM.

The features students need are free. The three things a college student uses most, gram-level macro targets, barcode scanning and scanning a label or a plate, are all behind MyFitnessPal's Premium tier. On Caf Coach they are free, and there is no 7-day trial that turns into a charge.

Where MyFitnessPal is ahead

MyFitnessPal has the biggest food database in the category, exercise logging, Apple Health and Google Fit sync, recipe import, and years of integrations with scales and watches. If you cook most of your meals, eat out a lot, or want one app for food and workouts, it is the more complete diary. Caf Coach does not track exercise and does not sync with Apple Health yet.

Which one should you pick?

If you eat most meals in a campus dining hall, use Caf Coach: it removes the searching, builds the plan, and costs nothing. If you cook or eat out most of the time and want workouts in the same app, MyFitnessPal fits better. Plenty of students use Caf Coach for the dining hall and keep MyFitnessPal for everything else. Whichever you use, cafeteria nutrition data comes from the dining service and can be imprecise, so treat totals as a good estimate and confirm allergens at the hall.

Sources

  • MyFitnessPal Premium page, myfitnesspal.com/premium: "$79.99/ year", "$19.99/ month"; comparison table listing Barcode Scan & Meal Scan, Macro Tracking with Custom Goals and Ad-Free Logging as Premium-only; 7-day trial terms. Checked November 8, 2026.
  • Caf Coach campus count from our live campus list at cafcoach.org/api/campuses (304 on November 8, 2026).

Common questions

Does MyFitnessPal have college dining hall menus?

No. MyFitnessPal is a general food database. Some dining services upload items to it, but there is no menu for your hall and no way to see what is being served today. Caf Coach loads today's menu at 304 schools.

Is barcode scanning free on MyFitnessPal?

No. As of November 8, 2026, MyFitnessPal lists Barcode Scan and Meal Scan as Premium-only features. Premium is $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year. Barcode, photo and label scanning are free on Caf Coach.

Can I set macro goals in grams on the free MyFitnessPal?

No. Gram-level custom macro goals are a Premium feature on MyFitnessPal. Caf Coach's calculator sets gram targets for cut, maintain, bulk or recomp for free.

Should I switch from MyFitnessPal to Caf Coach?

If most of your meals come from a dining hall, yes, at least for those meals. If you cook or eat out most days and track workouts, keep MyFitnessPal. Many students use both.

Caf Coach is free. No subscription, no locked features, no card.

Get started free

Or see how it works first.

About this page: written by the Caf Coach team, so read it as our view. Every fact about another product comes from that product's own public website or App Store page on the date above, with links in Sources. Product names are trademarks of their owners and are used only to identify them. Caf Coach is general information, not medical or dietary advice.